After Election Day, news did slow down to a point. Once January kicks in, that expects to be a different story. Now, the CFTC had a pretty good record against the California tribes and their council. Yes, this war with the prediction markets feels like it will go on forever. Add in the sudden electoral swing in Congress and this has the makings of becoming a total mess. This latest war between the states and federal government expects to escalate in 2027.
Honestly, the Attorney General of California letting the tribes do the work is wise. One of the telling realities that online betting sites have not accepted is the following. So, California knows that have the legislative branch on their side from a state and federal standpoint. However, the potential for division is high given how polarized politics is in general.
Again and again, the Supreme Court ruling on potential cases feels like something that could be on the menu later in 2027. For all the state and district court decisions and stays, the highest court in the land could see cases then. This is not just for prediction markets. Regulations for sports gambling represent different problems. Currently, different states have alignments that might surprise even the casual reader.
Rob Bonta appears to be more successful the less he does here. California has more pressing issues. The reality is maybe letting the tribes duke it out with the government is the play. Surely, DraftKings, FanDuel, and other entities are keenly watching.
The tribes win one against Kalshi
California and prediction markets do the two-step. The California National Indian Gaming Association is looking out for its own interests, the Las Vegas odds prove that the state’s most effective resource may be the tribes themselves versus Kalshi, Polymarket, etc. Do remember how the Circuit Court has split in certain matters. Just because a federal judge ruled for the tribes, it only makes more of a mess.
The problem here is DraftKings, Polymarket, PrizePicks, and Kalshi as examples of prediction markets that have squirreled their way into the biggest state in the United States. California again, has one of the largest five economies in the hemisphere. Going where the money is also draws the most attention.
As for that DCM issue, this is where things get intriguing. Often what people fail to understand here is that the shell game is ongoing. Prediction markets are based on contracts (Designated Contract Market) and yet get marketed as gambling. If one sees the advertising in these states, the legality feels like it is disclosed enough times to monopolize the entire commercial.
California tribes saw what the interface looked like for Kalshi and saw red. Predictably, when the Ninth Circuit put the Kalshi screen up next to DraftKings and FanDuel, the appearance was obvious. They looked pretty similar to the naked eye — actually very similar.
The Supreme Court dilemma
Yes, the Supreme Court remains the final battle, and it is quite obvious. Consider that California has an AG opinion that is toothless. States want their rights to tax and regulate the markets. Many states want these prediction markets done. It is like blocking all deposit methods via the courts. Everyone fights over money but the Tribes want their money first.
California waited too long as the prediction markets have been just enough ahead to this end. Some will say the Golden State is trying to wait things out while running out the clock. Unfortunately, they are at the mercy of how the highest court rules on two major provisions. One is the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) and the other is the exclusive jurisdiction and how it truly applies to Kalshi and the states.
Alas, the state’s authority has some merit and legal standing. How much of that is preserved is another question entirely. The irony is that Congress has an avenue to regulate such “swaps”. Murphy V. NCAA is a 2018 case that gives them some legal room here. With so many cases, the Federal part of the government has sided with the prediction markets while the states and those PM’s continue to wage war.
Prediction markets will now exist in California well into 2027 and possibly beyond. That is now the reality. Even with the case having proof and standing, DraftKings and other prediction markets can continue to tie cases up using cases across the United States as precedent. Split verdicts continue to muddy the gambling landscape in California at a minimum.
What does the Post Election Day landscape look like?
Yes, the post-Election Day landscape looks like a mess in California. California needs the tribes to continue the fight basically as the state looks to avoid the legal gambling question almost altogether. Their laissez-faire approach probably yields more fruit at this juncture.
Now, California’s financial picture continues to bleed more and more red. With the Federal Government investigating other aspects of their economy, that probably will keep the Attorney General and the legal arm of California far more occupied.
This approach in California makes sense. They want a patchwork where Kalshi and other prediction markets answer to the state. Meanwhile, the CFTC prefers one body for potential regulation. With the circuit courts in an undeniable stalemate, again the inevitable step is the highest court in the land.
California and other states know this which is why they have met all the deadlines while prediction markets try to stall them. The cat-and-mouse game will come to an end and given how the Justices are even split within their own parties on this, no one truly knows the eventual results.
Chris Wassel is someone who has covered a little bit of everything: business, writing, sports, food, grilling, the Olympics, injuries, politics, and more. He has climbed mountains like Mount Washington and Mount San Jacinto in Palm Springs, California, and for those who don’t know, he is also big into food challenges. With friends like Joey Chestnut and Casey Webb, Chris has tackled eating feats like finishing a 16-pound turkey or a 32-inch meat lover's pizza.
Since 2013, he has focused on fitness, fishing, and sports while managing to fit in running, hiking, rock climbing, and even the occasional mini-triathlon. He can lift more than his body weight with ease and is the person you turn to when you want to know if a NASCAR rain delay means a Monday race.
Over his career, Chris has worked at places like Amazon, USA Today, and various rumors and fantasy sports sites. He has been nominated for awards such as the Fantasy Sports Writers Association's Hockey Writer of the Year and has a collection of high-stakes fantasy trophies and rings on display at home. With all this, Chris sums it up best with his motto: "Shut up and play."